Agoda Hero Banner

Fire Island (NY) hotels & places to stay

Search to compare prices and discover great deals with free cancellation

Hotels in Fire Island (NY)

Star rating
Review score
Our top picks
Lowest price first
Nearest to
Best reviewed
Fire Island Pines Rooms
Fire Island Pines,Fire Island (NY) - View on map
  1. Beach
  2. Free Wi-Fi
  3. Swimming pool
  4. Pets allowed
  5. Balcony/Terrace
  6. Laundry
  7. Smoke-free property
  8. Air conditioning in public area
10

Exceptional

1 review

Avg price per night
USD 239
The Madison Fire Island Pines
Fire Island Pines,Fire Island (NY) - View on map
  1. Beach
  2. Free Wi-Fi
  3. Swimming pool
  4. Massage
  5. Pets allowed
  6. Balcony/Terrace
  7. Garden
  8. Breakfast
Come As You Are Inn LLC
Fire Island Pines,Fire Island (NY) - View on map
  1. Free Wi-Fi
  2. Free parking
  3. Bar
  4. Balcony/Terrace
  5. Garden
  6. Laundry
  7. Non-smoking rooms
  8. Air conditioning in public area
Glamorous Pines Home - Fire Island Pines, NY
Fire Island Pines,Fire Island (NY) - View on map
  1. Free Wi-Fi
  2. Swimming pool
  3. Free parking
  4. Family room
  5. Balcony/Terrace
  6. Garden
  7. Non-smoking rooms
  8. Air conditioning in public area
Cherry Grove Enchantment
Fire Island Pines,Fire Island (NY) - View on map
  1. Beach
  2. Free Wi-Fi
  3. Hot tub
  4. Contactless check-in/out
  5. Laundry
  6. Non-smoking rooms
  7. Air conditioning in public area
  8. Heating
Luxury 3-bedroom Pines house with 360-degree views
Fire Island Pines,Fire Island (NY) - View on map
  1. Free Wi-Fi
  2. Swimming pool
  3. Pets allowed
  4. Balcony/Terrace
  5. Smoke-free property
  6. BBQ facilities
  7. Air conditioning in public area
  8. English

Fast facts about Fire Island (NY), United States

Accommodations4 properties
Popular hotelGrove Hotel
Popular areaFire Island Pines
Nightly rates from$180

Where to stay in Fire Island (NY)


Frequently asked questions

What resorts in Fire Island (NY) have the best breakfast?

Verified vacationers to Fire Island (NY) have given top rated reviews for the breakfast at The Madison Fire Island Pines.

What are the prime properties in Fire Island (NY) intended for individual travelers?

Hotels in Fire Island (NY) which are very highly rated by lone tourists are Grove Hotel, Fire Island Pines Rooms and The Madison Fire Island Pines.

What are the recommended accommodations in Fire Island (NY) for business travelers?

Hotels in Fire Island (NY) which are well rated by business travelers are Grove Hotel, Fire Island Pines Rooms and The Madison Fire Island Pines.

What are the very best resorts around Fire Island (NY) for group travelers?

Properties found in Fire Island (NY) which are highly rated by group tourists are Grove Hotel, Fire Island Pines Rooms and The Madison Fire Island Pines.

What are the most appropriate hotels around Fire Island (NY) that has complimentary parking?

Properties offering complimentary parking found in Fire Island (NY) which are very highly rated include Come As You Are Inn LLC, Come As You Are Inn LLC and Come As You Are Inn LLC.

What are the most suitable places to stay around Fire Island (NY) which have bars?

Resorts which have bars found in Fire Island (NY) that are highly rated include Come As You Are Inn LLC, Come As You Are Inn LLC and Come As You Are Inn LLC.

Where can I reserve rooms in Fire Island (NY) with free cancellation policy?

Yes, you’ll find the majority of hotel rooms offer free cancellation rates, with which you can expect to receive a full refund if you cancel prior to the deadline. Filter your search by free cancellation to find flexible hotel offers in Fire Island (NY).

Are international visitors allowed into Fire Island (NY)?

Foreign travelers are partially allowed into Fire Island (NY), based on our most up-to-date information. Due to evolving restrictions, we recommend you browse here for further details.

Is quarantine expected for fully vaccinated foreigners to enter Fire Island (NY)?

Quarantine is not required for fully vaccinated vacationers to enter Fire Island (NY) from outside the country. For updated and in depth information on travel restrictons, please check out the official websites of the travel authority or government of the country you wish to travel to, or go to here.

Is quarantine required for unvaccinated foreigners to enter Fire Island (NY)?

Quarantine may be required for unvaccinated visitors to enter Fire Island (NY) from outside the country. For up-to-date and detailed information on travel restrictons, please visit the official websites of the travel authority or government of the country you wish to travel to, or go to here.

Is pre-departure covid test expected for unvaccinated travelers to enter Fire Island (NY)?

Proof of negative pre-departure COVID-19 test may be required to enter Fire Island (NY). For updated and detailed information on travel restrictons, please visit the official websites of the travel authority or government of the country you wish to visit, or go to here.

What vaccines are recognized in Fire Island (NY)?

Moderna, Pfizer/BioNTech, Janssen (Johnson & Johnson), Oxford/AstraZeneca, Sinovac, Sinopharm/BIBP, Covishield, Covaxin, Novavax/Covovax, CanSinoBIO, Nuvaxovid (Novavax) are currently acknowledged and approved by the national health authority of the country that includes Fire Island (NY).

Show more questions


More about Fire Island (NY)

Discover the Fun Facts About Fire Island (NY), United States

Fire Island is a barrier island located off the south shore of Long Island, New York. It is a popular summer destination for tourists, attracting thousands of visitors each year. The island is approximately 31 miles long and varies in width from 520 feet to 1,310 feet. Fire Island is known for its stunning beaches, beautiful sunsets, and vibrant nightlife. Fun fact: Fire Island is home to the world's largest population of endangered piping plovers, a small shorebird that nests on the island's beaches.

Top Reasons Why You Should Visit Fire Island (NY) Now

Fire Island is a must-visit destination for travelers looking for a unique and unforgettable experience. Here are some of the top reasons why you should visit Fire Island now: - Beautiful beaches: Fire Island is home to some of the most beautiful beaches in the world. Whether you're looking to sunbathe, swim, or surf, you'll find the perfect spot on the island's 17 miles of pristine shoreline. - Vibrant nightlife: Fire Island is known for its vibrant nightlife. From beachfront bars to dance clubs, there's something for everyone on the island. The Pines and Cherry Grove are two of the most popular destinations for nightlife on Fire Island. - Outdoor activities: Fire Island offers a wide range of outdoor activities, including hiking, biking, kayaking, and fishing. The island's natural beauty makes it the perfect destination for outdoor enthusiasts. - LGBTQ-friendly: Fire Island has a long history as an LGBTQ-friendly destination. The island's two main communities, Cherry Grove and The Pines, are known for their welcoming and inclusive atmosphere.

How to Go to Fire Island (NY) Hassle-Free

Getting to Fire Island is easy and hassle-free. The island is accessible by ferry or private boat. If you're traveling from New York City, you can take the Long Island Railroad to Bay Shore or Sayville, where you can catch a ferry to Fire Island. If you're driving, you can park your car in one of the many parking lots near the ferry terminals. Once you arrive on the island, you can travel around by foot, bike, or water taxi.

Fun Things to Do in Fire Island (NY) for an Unforgettable Experience

Fire Island offers a wide range of activities for travelers looking for an unforgettable experience. Here are some of the top things to do on the island: - Beach hopping: With 17 miles of pristine shoreline, Fire Island is the perfect destination for beach lovers. Some of the most popular beaches on the island include Ocean Beach, Cherry Grove Beach, and The Pines Beach. - Wildlife watching: Fire Island is home to a wide range of wildlife, including deer, foxes, and a variety of bird species. The island's beaches are also home to the world's largest population of endangered piping plovers. - Nightlife: Fire Island is known for its vibrant nightlife. From beachfront bars to dance clubs, there's something for everyone on the island. The Pines and Cherry Grove are two of the most popular destinations for nightlife on Fire Island. - Outdoor activities: Fire Island offers a wide range of outdoor activities, including hiking, biking, kayaking, and fishing. The island's natural beauty makes it the perfect destination for outdoor enthusiasts. - Historical sites: Fire Island has a rich history, and there are several historical sites on the island that are worth visiting. Some of the most popular sites include the Fire Island Lighthouse and the Sunken Forest.

Why Book a Hotel in Fire Island (NY) with Agoda.com?

Agoda.com is the perfect platform for travelers looking to book a hotel in Fire Island. With a wide range of options to choose from, including the Come As You Are Inn, Grove Hotel, and The Madison Fire Island Pines, Agoda.com makes it easy to find the perfect accommodation for your needs. Plus, with Agoda.com's easy-to-use booking platform, you can book your hotel in just a few clicks. Whether you're looking for a budget-friendly option or a luxurious beachfront resort, Agoda.com has you covered.

The Best Time to Visit Fire Island (NY) and Why

The best time to visit Fire Island is during the summer months, from June to September. During this time, the weather is warm and sunny, and the island is bustling with activity. However, if you're looking for a quieter experience, you may want to consider visiting in the shoulder seasons of May or October. During these months, the weather is still pleasant, and the crowds are smaller.

Expert Tips for Travelers Visiting Fire Island (NY)

Here are some expert tips for travelers visiting Fire Island: - Pack light: Since there are no cars on Fire Island, you'll need to carry all of your luggage with you. Pack light and bring only the essentials. - Bring cash: Many businesses on Fire Island do not accept credit cards, so it's a good idea to bring cash with you. - Book your hotel in advance: Fire Island is a popular destination, and hotels can fill up quickly, especially during the summer months. Book your hotel in advance to ensure you get the best deal and the perfect accommodation for your needs. - Respect the wildlife: Fire Island is home to a wide range of wildlife, including the endangered piping plover. Respect the wildlife and follow any posted signs or guidelines.

Where to Stay in Fire Island (NY) for a Comfortable and Memorable Stay

Fire Island offers a wide range of accommodation options, from budget-friendly hotels to luxurious beachfront resorts. Here are some of the top hotels to consider when booking your stay on the island: - Come As You Are Inn: This charming bed and breakfast is located in Cherry Grove and offers comfortable rooms and a relaxing atmosphere. - Grove Hotel: This historic hotel is located in the heart of Cherry Grove and offers a range of room options, including suites and apartments. - The Madison Fire Island Pines: This luxurious beachfront resort is located in The Pines and offers stunning views of the ocean and a wide range of amenities, including a pool and a restaurant.

What to Eat in Fire Island (NY) for a Culinary Adventure

Fire Island offers a wide range of dining options, from casual beachfront cafes to fine dining restaurants. Here are some of the top places to eat on the island: - Island Mermaid: This popular restaurant in Ocean Beach offers a range of seafood dishes and stunning views of the ocean. - Canteen: This casual cafe in Fire Island Pines offers a range of healthy and delicious options, including smoothie bowls and salads. - Top of the Bay: This fine dining restaurant in Cherry Grove offers a range of gourmet dishes and stunning views of the bay.